The Red Sox’s acquisition of Garrett Crochet is a step in the right direction, but you’re absolutely correct: this isn’t the time to stop improving.
While the rotation looks solid on paper with Crochet, Tanner Houck, Brayan Bello, Lucas Giolito, and Kutter Crawford, the reality of a 162-game MLB season means depth is critical.
Injuries, underperformance, and unforeseen challenges often derail even the best-laid plans.
Adding Walker Buehler would be a savvy move for Boston, especially considering his postseason track record.
Despite his struggles in the regular season following his return from injury, his performance in the playoffs—and particularly in the World Series—underscores his value as a high-stakes performer. That kind of experience and poise is invaluable for a team with championship aspirations.
A two-year, $32 million deal seems reasonable for a pitcher of Buehler’s caliber, particularly given the potential upside if he regains his pre-injury form.
The Red Sox would not only be adding depth but also a proven winner with a history of thriving under pressure. Buehler’s presence could also take some of the load off younger arms like Bello and stabilize the rotation.
However, the Red Sox must weigh the risk. Buehler’s regular-season struggles in 2023 can’t be ignored, and his health remains a concern. They’ll need to ensure his medical evaluations are favorable and that his postseason resurgence wasn’t a mirage.
If Boston can secure him at a reasonable price, though, his addition could push this rotation from “solid” to “formidable.”
With Crochet and potentially Buehler, the Red Sox would not only have a rotation capable of competing in the regular season but one built for October—a necessity if they aim to return to the World Series.
