The San Diego Padres appear to face a critical decision regarding Jurickson Profar as the MLB Winter Meetings approach.
After signing Profar to a one-year deal before the 2024 season—a move that initially flew under the radar—the 31-year-old delivered a breakout campaign, posting a .280/.380/.459 slash line with 24 home runs.
However, his career-best performance has now complicated matters, as Profar hits free agency with a track record that makes assessing his market value challenging.
### Padres Prioritize Re-signing Profar
Insider AJ Cassavell has hinted that bringing Profar back could be a top priority for the Padres at the Winter Meetings. Profar’s affinity for San Diego and his success there compared to struggles elsewhere make him an appealing candidate to return.
Moreover, his departure would leave a significant void in the Padres’ outfield, especially given the team’s current roster needs.
### Financial Hurdles and Market Considerations
While the Padres’ desire to retain Profar is clear, their financial flexibility may be limited. Profar’s exceptional 2024 season, particularly his .380 on-base percentage, stands in stark contrast to his career .322 OBP, raising questions about whether his performance is sustainable.
If he seeks a multi-year deal with a high average annual value (AAV), it could present a challenge for San Diego, especially as the team balances other priorities, such as addressing pitching depth following Joe Musgrove’s injury.
### A Logical Fit
Despite these hurdles, re-signing Profar seems like a logical move for both parties. The Padres need a productive, bat-first outfielder, and Profar has proven to be a seamless fit with the team’s culture and on-field needs.
While his market value remains uncertain, losing him could prove costly in terms of roster construction and team chemistry.
