with Duncan Robinson’s shooting and Kel’el Ware’s potential, could create an intriguing core for the Hawks. The unprotected 2029 first-round pick from Miami sweetens the deal, giving Atlanta a long-term asset as well.”
This hypothetical trade presents a fascinating scenario for both teams:
For the Miami Heat:
- Upside: Trae Young brings elite playmaking and scoring, forming a formidable trio with Jimmy Butler and Bam Adebayo. Adding Larry Nance Jr. provides frontcourt depth and versatility.
- Risk: Giving up Tyler Herro, who’s emerging as a star, might backfire, especially considering his age and growth potential. Young’s defensive limitations could also strain Miami’s system.
For the Atlanta Hawks:
- Upside: Acquiring Tyler Herro fits perfectly with the Hawks’ youth movement. Kel’el Ware offers untapped potential as a big man, and Robinson bolsters their perimeter shooting. The unprotected pick provides long-term flexibility.
- Risk: Trading Trae Young—a franchise cornerstone—comes with inherent risk, especially if Herro doesn’t fully replicate Young’s offensive impact or if the pick doesn’t yield high value.
Analysis of Fit
- Miami would have to bank on Trae Young’s offensive brilliance outweighing Herro’s breakout year. Young would bring instant offense and potentially attract other stars.
- For Atlanta, this deal signals a clear pivot toward a younger, more balanced roster. Herro’s steady development and leadership could complement their young core led by Dyson Daniels and Zaccharie Risacher.
Is It Worth It?
- If the Heat believe they can maximize Jimmy Butler’s championship window, adding a proven All-Star like Young might make sense.
- The Hawks, on the other hand, must weigh Young’s long-term commitment against the opportunity to reset around younger talent.
Would you make this trade if you were Miami or Atlanta?
